3 Ways to Resolve a Business Ownership Dispute during Divorce

When a marriage ends and the couple owns a business together, the resulting dispute for ownership rights can get ugly. After all, a family business is considered property and thus can be subject to the equitable division of marital assets in a divorce.

Three Methods of Handling Your Business After Divorce

  • Continuing to run the business with your ex-spouse through co-ownership. This can be difficult, especially in the case of a contentious break-up. Any hostility whatsoever between ex-spouses can not only affect them personally but could also lead to disaster for the business itself. Unless you have a completely amicable relationship following the divorce and a high degree of trust in each other’s business skills, it is not advised to try co-owning the business.
  • Buying out your ex-spouse’s stake in the business. This can be done up front with enough cash or liquid assets or can be done by compromising on other monetary benefits such as home equity and retirement funds. It is also possible to enter into a property settlement note or structured settlement, which works like a loan with interest, a principal and a definite term to pay back.
  • Selling the business and splitting the resulting funds. This option is nice because the two parties can take their own separate profits and use them to fund their own future investments without needing to deal with the ex. However, it can take a long time for a business to be sold, so for couples seeking here-and-now solutions, this one may be less than ideal.

Consult with a Skilled Lawyer in Aurora Today

Especially in the case of a closely-held family business, the process of deciding who keeps what can be emotionally draining. If you are seeking a divorce and are unsure of how to handle the family business, speak to a family law attorney. You can learn more about other considerations you may need to make during divorce through our divorce Q&A.

Will My Spouse be Entitled to Part of My 401(k)?

Colorado is an equitable division state when it comes to marital property. This means that the judge will decide on a division of assets that he or she finds to be equitable and fair. If you have a substantial retirement account or 401(k) built up, your 401(k) can be subjected to this division.

Your 401(k) Will be Handled in One of Four Ways

  • You keep your retirement funds, and your spouse receives marital assets of comparable value. Assets can be anything with monetary worth ”“ cars and homes, to name two big examples.
  • You split your 401(k) assets with your spouse. To do this, you will need a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QRDO). A QRDO is a court order allowing your spouse to receive part of your account. QRDOs can be complicated, and you will be required to speak to both your divorce lawyer and your 401(k) plan administrator before the orders can be finalized.
  • You liquidate the portion of your account needed by a QRDO and pay your spouse with a lump sum. This method has some tax consequences and is generally considered worthwhile only in extreme cases.
  • If you have left your company and are over 59 ½ years old, you can roll your ex’s portion of the 401(k) into an IRA. This is an attractive option as it allows you to separate your funds from your ex’s without any penalties or tax liability.

If you need help determining what the best option is for your 401(k) in your divorce, contact a Denver divorce attorney. The team at Divorce Matters can help answer all of your questions and ensure that you are treated fairly both during and after your divorce

How to Navigate a House Buyout in Divorce

Ownership of the family home can be one of the most difficult things to negotiate with your spouse during the divorce process. Your spouse may resist if you want to keep the house or vice versa. A common way of dealing with this dispute is for one party to “buy out” the other for half of the home’s value.

Buyouts are not without risk. Home value fluctuates over time. Whichever party sells out his or her portion of the home (usually the noncustodial parent, if the couple has kids) could risk missing potential appreciation of the home’s value as the market changes; likewise, the buying party could feel that the price was too high if the home’s value falls. Buyouts can happen over time but usually occur as part of a divorce settlement.

Determining a Home’s Value in a Divorce

The simplest method of getting an estimate for your home’s value is to speak with a real estate agent about recent home sales in your neighborhood for houses similar to yours. They call these “comps” ”“ comparable rates.

If you do not trust the comps, you and your spouse can jointly hire an appraiser. Appraisers generally charge between $300 and $500 dollars for a formal report on your home’s worth and can help you and your spouse come to an agreement on a buyout price, especially if you and your spouse have different opinions of how much the house is worth. If you and your spouse disagree on the appraiser’s assessment, you can each have your own appraiser give a report. This can lead to issues at trial when the appraisal prices are far apart, a fairly common scenario in divorce courts. You can also ask a judge to decide on the value of the home, but in all likelihood, the judge will refer to the appraisers’ reports.

Obtaining Funds for the Buyout

After appraisals are made, there is the question of where to obtain the funds to do the buyout. Usually, the party keeping the house will have to refinance to buy out the other spouse. Alternatively, they can assume the mortgage payments and offer other property as payment for the home’s equity.

Home buyouts become even more complicated when children are involved, but can also create more options, such as a long-term plan for a buyout. If the spouse staying in the home does not qualify for a refinance and does not have the money for a buyout, it is not uncommon for him or her to continue to pay the mortgage until the kids turn 18, after which the home would be refinanced or sold and the payments delivered to the ex-spouse.

Talk to a Divorce Attorney Today to Discuss Your Options

Deciding who keeps the marital home can be stressful, but it doesn’t have to be. If you have any questions about how to choose, the costs of appraisal, or whether you might be able to negotiate home ownership by compromising on other financial aspects of divorce, speak with an Aurora divorce attorney.

How Can I Keep My Car during Divorce?

One thing that can be overlooked when preparing or undergoing a divorce is the question of who keeps the car. This can get especially heated in situations where the couple only owns one vehicle, so we’ve taken the time to field some questions about how divorce affects car ownership.

Q: If the car was purchased after our marriage, who gets to keep it?

A: The car is considered marital property and is subject to equitable division of marital assets.

Q: Can I keep my car if the car is in my spouse’s name?

A: Generally speaking, the name on the title does not determine absolute ownership of the car. It could still be considered marital property, especially if purchased during a marriage. If the car is purchased prior to marriage, there could still be a portion of equity in the car that is marital and subject to division. For these situations, it is wise to speak with a divorce attorney as well as your spouse to determine who gets to keep the car. If working this issue out with your ex is going to be contentious, consider divorce mediation.

Q: If both of our names are on the title, how do I get possession of the car?

A: You are probably going to have to work this one out with your spouse, but if he or she refuses to give up the vehicle, you can ask for a court order to take possession of the vehicle. The court will enter an interim order for exclusive rights to certain property. Once a final order of possession is entered, the party not keeping the car will be ordered to sign over the title.

Q: If my spouse bought me a car as a wedding gift, will I have to give it back to him or her?

A: Gifts can be considered separate property and thus not subject to equitable division. However, even if a car is purchased by one party and given to the other party, it can still be considered a marital asset subject to division. Gifts from one spouse to the other during a marriage cannot be presumed to be gifts. There must be an intention and acceptance of the gift as separate property.

Q: We shared a car during our marriage, and I still have a spare key. Is it legal for me to go and take the car?

A: It’s a bad idea. Aside from the legal implications of such an act, especially if your name is not on the title for the car, this could lead to animosity between you and your ex, which is something that you do not need more of during a divorce. If your name is on the title, then you do have an ownership interest; however, it is still best to discuss the car with a divorce attorney rather than taking the car outright. If the court has already given exclusive right to the car to one spouse, the other is not permitted to take the car.

Divorce Matters ”“ Denver Family Law Attorneys

How Can a Business Valuator Help My Divorce Case?

When it comes to dividing assets during a divorce, businesses can be a complicated issue. Marital businesses are assets the court must objectively divide. If there is disagreement over what a business is worth or how to divide the martial property, the court may use a business valuator.

Who can be a business valuator?
Business valuators can be financial analysts, business appraisers, certified public accountants, or business brokers. Our Attorneys of Divorce Matters tells us, “Having used a number of these professionals in the Denver area, finding the right person makes all the difference. These professionals are experts in estimating the economic value of a business, which is more than the sum of its parts.”

How will they determine the value?
When valuing a business or professional practice in a divorce case, a court “must consider both the tangible and intangible assets, including the accounts receivable, the value of work in progress, and goodwill.” There are multiple methods to valuating a business, the court will make a decision about which valuation method is used.

Why is it important to use a valuator?
In Colorado, the court has power to assign value to a business as long as it can support its conclusion. It will be worth your time to carefully consider the financial circumstances surrounding the business. Every lemonade stand does not have a value worth determining. However, a long-standing business with a long track record of producing income may have a substantial good-will value in addition to the excess earnings it produces, a valuator will give you an objective opinion.

When it comes to determining how much your business is worth don’t take the word of your partner. Using a neutral third party will help both sides know the realistic value of the business without worrying about misrepresentations.

Filing for Divorce? Here’s How to Decide Who Stays in the Family Home

You’ve looked each other in the eye, announced your intentions, and are now ready to formally proceed with a divorce. In the weeks to come, a judge will likely set temporary orders to establish an interim parenting plan and provisional possession of the marital home, but that won’t help you figure out who’s going to sleep in the house tonight, or the next night, or the one after that.

As you prepare to file for divorce, use this guide to sort out a short-term living situation for your family”” and remember, always act in the best interests of your children.

Is Divorcing the Cure? Separating for Healthcare Benefits


Captain and Tennille’s
recent divorce announcement shocked quite a few members of our office, but between renditions of “Muskrat Love” and reminisces of their ”˜70s heyday, we also debated whether there was more to their split than “irreconcilable differences.” Although we’ve written plenty about the “gray divorce revolution,” the odds were ever in their favor. It’s rare for a couple over 50, who have been married for 35 years or more, to separate””unless, however, they’re doing so to protect their assets and to claim certain social benefits.

The media was quick to latch on to this theory as well, citing Obamacare and health insurance as the straw that snapped the entertainment duo’s 39-year-old marriage. It certainly isn’t a preposterous presumption. The Captain (aka Daryl Dragon), 71, suffers from a neurological condition similar to Parkinson’s disease, and likely requires expensive full-time care. Instead of completely depleting their joint assets, a single Captain could qualify for Medicaid””in addition to Medicare–health plans that would possibly supply him with long-term assisted living and pay for clinical-trial treatments. Since they filed in Arizona, a community-property state that splits everything 50-50, he would only exhaust his own resources and Tennille, 73, would still have something left to see her into the twilight years.

This is all pure speculation, of course, but overwhelming healthcare costs have long forced committed couples to divorce. In one case, a couple divorced so the wife could claim her deceased first husband’s social security benefits to help pay medical bills and to keep food on the table. In another, a couple about to celebrate their 50th wedding anniversary dissolved their marriage in order to qualify for Medicaid to cover the wife’s weekly chemotherapy treatments. There could even be a rise in this trend with the Affordable Care Act, as a “potential marriage penalty” requires certain couples (particularly those without children, like Captain and Tennille) to pay significantly more for plans than their single counterparts.

On the other hand, it’s also commonplace for couples to stay together solely for retirement and health insurance benefits. In fact, remaining on your spouse’s healthcare plan is one of the main reasons legal separation is becoming a popular alternative to divorce in Colorado””though continued coverage isn’t always guaranteed.

As for Captain and Tennille, we may never know why love didn’t keep them together. Don’t lose all faith quite yet though. There’s always the possibility they could remarry after the Captain claims his hypothetical healthcare benefits””you know, in case once just wasn’t enough with a man like him.

Why Vacation Days Count in a Divorce

After much back-and-forth, the Colorado Supreme Court has decided that vacation and sick days do, in fact, count as shared marital property. This doesn’t mean you’ll need to give your ex-spouse a few extra days off in the event of a divorce; rather, you’ll need to share the monetary value of that personal leave with him or her. Likewise, members of the military who are still eligible to “cash in” their leave will likely see that listed as a marital asset subject to equitable division as well.

The ruling stems from Cardona v. Castro (2014), whose permanent orders accounted for the husband’s accrued, but unused, personal days when dividing their marital property. The wife in this case stated that her husband had earned 452 hours (nearly 19 days) of paid leave; his salary was then calculated at $51.40 per hour, bringing the total value of his personal days to a whopping $23,232.80.

Regardless of whether he was entitled to any cash compensation for his outstanding personal time, the trial court awarded the wife half the sum and required the husband to pay her $11,616.00.

There was a series of appeals, but the Supreme Court’s recent ruling means that a spouse’s accrued vacation and sick days are marital property– and are subject to equitable division– IF the value of that leave can be reasonably calculated. In other words, the wife in Cardona v. Castro should not have been awarded half of her husband’s paid personal leave because there was no proof that he would be monetarily reimbursed for that unused time were he to leave his job.

Several companies eventually force employees to use their time-off and don’t ensure that unused days will roll-over to the next year, so it is worth reviewing your company’s policy regarding personal time. Do those days have an economic value that could find its way into your bank account one day, or are they simply a perk of the job?

Alternatively, it might just be time to splurge on that two-week vacation in the Caribbean after all.

A Dog in the Fight: Pets and Divorce

Nearly 68 percent of U.S. households owned pets in 2013, and so it’s only natural that we would turn to our four-legged friends for comfort as a marriage collapses. What happens to man’s best friend during a divorce though?

While we might treat our pets as integral members of the family, most courts consider them to be personal property– similar to a car or diamond necklace. Last year, however, a New York judge filed a landmark custody suit over Joey, a miniature dachshund whose parents were both desperate to keep him. The judge planned to treat Joey like a child by ultimately determining which spouse would best serve his interests, asking questions such as:

Ӣ Who spent more time with the dog on a regular basis?
Ӣ Who financially supported him on a primary basis?
Ӣ Who would now be most able to cater to his needs?

The case was eventually settled out of court, with one spouse surrendering permanent custody to the other, but it could still play a major role in treating pets less like property and more like human beings in the future.

As this case proves, simply raising a claim is often enough to expose which spouse really wants to keep the pet and the issue rarely appears before a judge. Unfortunately, however, some partners will also see the pets as “bargaining chips,” as in a case involving a herd of llamas. The husband had no personal attachment to the animals, but he wanted half of them anyway because he knew how dear they were to his wife and he expected her to sacrifice something else to keep them all together, said Maria Cognett of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers.

In Colorado, the general rule is that pets are property–whether it’s a herd of cattle in our state’s more rural communities, or the doomed goldfish sitting beside you– and should be equally divided as such. In light of that, one thing to consider is letting the pet stay with whomever gets primary custody of the children; that way, they don’t lose a furry friend along with a parent. Alternatively, if you can agree to a pet co-parenting plan with your ex-spouse, make sure the custody is for a significant period of time as animals find it more difficult to adjust to new surroundings and routines than humans. And once the inevitable comes, you may want to share your animal companion’s remains with your ex-spouse as well””just don’t fill the urn with ashes from the fireplace.

Please contact one of our well-informed lawyers if you’re concerned about how divorce might affect one of your beloved pets.

Preparing for Divorce: Finances, Kids, and Protecting Your Interests

There comes a point when you must admit your marriage is over.  You’ve tried everything from marriage counseling, personal therapy, and maybe even living apart.

But before you take the plunge, the best attorneys advise that you will fare much better if you prepare. It may seem heartless, but if you plan on getting divorced, or if you think your spouse may want one from you, there are some matters you should take care of first.  Addressing these issues before your partner even realizes you are ready to get divorced and you will be ahead of the game during the legal negotiations that will occur sooner than you think.

We know that the notion of a pending divorce”“even one not yet broached with your spouse”“can send you into a tailspin. The mere thought of getting divorced can cause a range of emotions, including relief, fear, disappointment, excitement, and dread.  But no matter what you feel, you must push these emotions aside and take some practical and strategic steps before anyone else gets the ball rolling:

1. Hire a lawyer that practices in the Denver Metro area.  Unless you have been married for only a short time, or you have no property or children, hire a lawyer. Even if you and your spouse have “worked everything out,” or have chosen a mediator, your personal family attorney may tell you about rights you did not know you had.  Remember, you do not need an F. Lee Bailey, but you should find someone who has handled divorces before, someone you can afford, and someone with whom you feel comfortable. Word of mouth is usually a good way to locate attorneys, but do not go by recommendations alone. Meet a few lawyers before making up your mind. This will help you learn about the differences in legal style between lawyers and help you find one that is good for you.

2. Learn your spouse’s annual income. Do they have a salaried position, or is paid by the hour, the information should be on a recent pay stub. If you cannot get one, last year’s tax return should help.  If your spouse is self-employed, a tax return may not tell you the full story.  Do a little detective work. Does your spouse have a partner? Are you friendly with the partner’s spouse? They may know about the business and be willing to share what they know about it.  Is someone else in the partnership divorced? That partner’s former spouse might be willing and able to help you.

3. Realistically assess what you can earn. Have you been out of the job market for a while? Perhaps you need some time to get your skills up to speed before taking the plunge. Has business been off lately? Keep a record of that now, so no one later accuses you of deliberately reducing your income to negotiate a more favorable settlement.

4. Learn everything there is to know about your family’s financial assets and liabilities.  You will only be able to share in assets you know about, so you must find out exactly what the two of you have. For most, that’s probably easy. There’s a house (owned by the bank), a car (still owned by the dealer), a pension (not yet vested), and a little bit of savings. But for some, property ownership is more complicated. In some cases, one spouse’s business is a marital asset to be valued, and a judge can distribute its value. The same may go for a ski house or condominium, even if inherited during the marriage.

5. Realistically assess your family’s debt. Often, the allocation of debt is harder to prove or negotiate than the division of assets. What debts do you have? Credit card, personal loans, bank loans, car loans? How much does it cost to pay these debts each month?

6. Make photocopies of every family financial record you can find. Canceled checks, bank statements, tax returns, life insurance polices”“if it is there, copy it.  You may never need this information, but if you do, it is good to have.

7. Make a list of your family’s valuables. Inventory your safety deposit box or family safe and take photographs of the contents. Do the same with jewelry or any furniture, paintings, or other items of value. You needn’t list every worn out piece of furniture, but anything with a value of more than $250, or that has value to you, or your spouse, should be included.

8. Learn how much it costs to run your household now. Whether you plan to stay in the home or leave, unless you know what the monthly costs are, you will not be able to determine how much money you need. If you’re the one who pays the monthly bills, your job is easy. If you are not, look through a checkbook to find the expenses”“how much is the monthly rent or mortgage; utilities, including electricity, heat, and phone; and maintenance costs such as snow removal, yard care, and annual maintenance for the house.  One woman we know, a well-educated profession, who had a full-time career, did not know the first thing about the family’s monthly expenses because her husband’s business secretary made out the checks and paid the bills from the office. She was embarrassed to confess her “ignorance,” but she is not alone.

9. Determine where you will live following separation. If you’re the spouse who plans to move out, decide where you are going to live and figure out how much it will cost you on a month-by-month basis beforehand. This will make your case much more difficult to settle.  Consider what it will cost to move and calculate start-up expenses, including telephone installation and turning on electricity and cable.

10. Save money, if at all possible. One unemployed wife of successful business owner wanted a divorce immediately. Her divorce lawyer, however, convinced her to be patient.  He advised her that it would be better to wait a year before filing for divorce.  During that time, she was instructed to save enough money, hopefully, to move out and pay for her expenses on her own.  It was not easy, but the wife saved enough to move out a year later.  After she was settled in her own apartment, her lawyer then went to court and got the judge to order her husband to pay her monthly rent until the divorce was finalized.  If the wife had not moved out, the judge could not have directed the husband to pay her rent because she wouldn’t have had any rent to pay.  Instead, she might have been stuck in the house, with her husband, until the divorce was final or forced to spend her meager savings on rent; and that could have taken far more than a year. (While most Judges will address the non-working spouse temporary support, you cannot count getting temporary maintenance or the amount of the maintenance.)

11. Build up your own credit. If you don’t have credit cards in your own name, apply for them now. You may be able to get them now, based on your spouse’s income, and you will probably need credit later. Use the cards instead of cash and pay the bill by the due date.

12. Stay involved or increase your involvement with your children. First, this is important for your children because they will need all the support and reassurance they can get during the unsteady and hectic times ahead.   Plus, courts consider the depth and quality of your relationship when making custody and visitation decisions.  Therefore, more involvement now could translate to continued involvement, at a higher level, after the divorce, as well as the custody agreement you want and is best for your children.  Take a look at your own behavior.  Have you been so busy earning a living that you have let your spouse do the majority of work raising your children?  If so, now is the time to reallocate your priorities. If you have school-age children, help them get ready for school in the morning, help them with homework at night, and help get them to bed. Learn who their teachers are, who their doctors are, and their friends. If your children are not yet in school, spend as much time with them as you can before and after work. Even if you do not have much of a chance in getting custody, you will become a better parent and have a better relationship with your children.  Take heed from a much-publicized custody battle involving a famous film director and his former partner.  The father’s case for joint custody was severely weakened when the judge learned he did not know the names of his children’s pets or teachers, or their shoe sizes. Although many parents may not know their child’s shoe size, the Mother’s lawyer made a big deal out of it.

13. Withdrawing money from the bank. If you fear your request for divorce will send your spouse straight to the bank, withdraw half of the money in all your savings accounts first. Place the money in a new account, and keep it there until you and your spouse can work out the distribution of property. Do not spend the money if at all possible. If the money is in a checking account and you know the account is nearly emptied every month to pay bills, do not withdraw any part of that money. You will create financial mayhem if checks bounce.

14. Consider canceling charge cards. If you are the party responsible for paying credit card bills, consider canceling your accounts”“or at least reducing the spending limit.  Often times, the announcement of a divorce causes one party to go on a shopping spree.

If you have additional questions, contact Divorce Matters, and arrange to meet with an experienced denver divorce attorney.  Divorce Matters helps clients throughout the Metro Denver area get the best results possible in their divorce and child custody matters.